78
edits
Difference between revisions of "Talk:Jambiya"
Comment
(Comment) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I fail to see why both the [[Tavern | I fail to see why both the [[Tavern in the Port]] and [[Jambiya]] have the same wares listed, when none of the other bars/bartender pages that I see do this. Jambiya doesn't appear to sell anything herself (that is, by asking her), you simply look at the tavern wares. [[User:Soludra|Soludra]] 02:08, 21 September 2008 (UTC) | ||
:It was moved before we could agree on exactly what was happening with the Tavern in the Port article. Personally, I agree with you, but the issue (I think) was that unless a tavern or a bar had a formal name, there should not be an article for it. Instead, the shop wares would be listed in the shop proprietor's article (example: [[Yuli]]). This is because we decided we did not want articles called "A warmly lit tavern." or whatnot. I don't particularly like that policy, but that's what we have for now. (I'd prefer listing wares with the denizen only if the denizen actually sells the items, otherwise it gets confusing/misleading. Also, a tavern/bar with no formal name is still a tavern/bar and should be included in our tavern/bar category in order for our wiki to be comprehensive/complete. The lack of a proper noun should not be sufficient means for exclusion from that category.) [[User:Asara|Asara]] 03:25, 22 September 2008 (UTC) | :It was moved before we could agree on exactly what was happening with the Tavern in the Port article. Personally, I agree with you, but the issue (I think) was that unless a tavern or a bar had a formal name, there should not be an article for it. Instead, the shop wares would be listed in the shop proprietor's article (example: [[Yuli]]). This is because we decided we did not want articles called "A warmly lit tavern." or whatnot. I don't particularly like that policy, but that's what we have for now. (I'd prefer listing wares with the denizen only if the denizen actually sells the items, otherwise it gets confusing/misleading. Also, a tavern/bar with no formal name is still a tavern/bar and should be included in our tavern/bar category in order for our wiki to be comprehensive/complete. The lack of a proper noun should not be sufficient means for exclusion from that category.) [[User:Asara|Asara]] 03:25, 22 September 2008 (UTC) | ||
::Agreed. "Tavern at the Port" seems like a valid tavern name, noting the capital P, whereas "A warmly lit tavern" obviously isn't. Maybe we should have an ''Unnamed taverns'' page which lists those kinds of taverns and their wares. [[User:Soludra|Soludra]] 01:15, 23 September 2008 (UTC) | |||